Guideline and Publications
Proposal for Research/Publications made from BAETS database material.
- The database to have appropriate responsibility taken for data entry by individual members as a form of data validation.
- Members to be acknowledged formally for their roles in data collection and patient care.
- A citation for published work that can be searched on Medline and PubMed.
- Full Members (Main author – MA) can apply for a data set from the database that is required to answer the questions proposed by the aims of their research project. They do this via a revised application form (attached). This form is distributed to the Exec who are given 10 days to respond. If no response is given, then it is assumed they agree to that project being approved and data released. The data released to the member can only be used for the approved research project that was applied for.
- Approved data set is given to the MA that applied for this along with the names of BAETS members that are eligible to be collaborators for that data set. The member undertaking the research then analyses the data and prepares the manuscript up to the point they feel it is ready for submission (proposed final manuscript). The proposed final manuscript is sent to the potential collaborators along with the intended journals author declaration form. The Potential collaborators have 10 days to return the declaration form and any suggestions or queries to the MA responsible for the manuscript preparation.
- From this the MA can create a final manuscript that has the names of all those eligible collaborators that have returned completed author declaration forms cited as collaborators with any involved collaborator comments used to improve the final manuscript at the discretion of the MA. This final manuscript is then sent out to the revised author group who
- This number is to be agreed at a BAETS national meeting, but propose it is based on GIRFT recommended numbers of, 20 thyroid/year, 20 parathyroid/year and 6 adrenal/year. An alternative could be 30 thyroid/parathyroid cases per year? TBC.
- The full author list is still composed of those that have developed the concept, materials and analysis as named authors along with the Name ‘BAETS Researchers’ included at some point in the list order to be decided by the Main author group.
- The revised application form is attached to this email. Full members can create their own research team to run this project but communication between that team and the BAETS is via the full member who takes full responsibility for the use of the data provided to them from the database by the members of their research team. The full member and MA should contact the Director of Audit as their initial contact point. then have 3 days to retract their desire to be named as a collaborator. (If collaborator involvement requires listing, then it is for their substantial contribution to: ‘data collection’, ‘care of data subjects’ and ‘manuscript preparation’).
- The MA can now submit this final manuscript to the journal minus the names of any retracted collaborator names.
- Journal requested alterations are dealt with by the MA /MA group. If help or guidance is required from the Collaborator group, the MA can do this solely via the BAETS Exec to reduce waits and create a single point of reference. However, it is assumed substantial changes that fundamentally change the message of the paper would not usually be accepted and would require a re-submission. If substantial changes were required, then point 3-5 is repeated in the timescales of points 3-5. This then becomes repeated until the manuscript is accepted for publication.
- At no point once an eligible collaborator has decided they do not wish to be involved will they be asked again for that manuscript. If the manuscript is sent to a new journal, then the sequence and timescales return to point 2 in this list, except the list of collaborators will be the list given at the previous manuscript submission.
The offer to be made to members after the webinar on 14th Sept is an option to create their own research groups using the database as a backbone for individual group datasets. This can be used as an alternative to redcap or any other independent collator of data for a research project. E-Dendrite would build it into the group members database as an additional page. The cost to be borne by the funding of the research project and not the BAETS
I have devised this proposal based on the guidance from CRediT and the ICMJE and NLM Technical Bulletin
It meets the criteria for authorship based on:
- Substantial involvement via collation of data and care of data subjects as without this the study would not have been possible.
- Input to manuscript preparation.
- Agree to the final manuscript.
- Provide a signed declaration of responsibility for the dataset used.
An alternative was to cite as contributors based on their collection of data and care for data subjects but this requires the same level of work from the MA group as a group author title and listing of collaborators. I think this is an improvement on the current system. Allows members to easily be involved in the use of the data they collect and makes them responsible for it. We can avoid a whittling down of numbers of subjects by not removing individual members contributions if they fail to agree to signing author declarations, but they are no longer responsible for any conclusions made from that dataset.